EagleTribune.com, North Andover, MA

Merrimack Valley

January 4, 2013

Educators tout new grading system

NORTH ANDOVER — Superintendent Kevin Hutchinson and other school officials have their work cut out for them.

If they want the new standards-based grading system to succeed, they need to iron out the inconsistencies in the marks given to students. They must also get parents “on board,” said Thomas Holland, the father of an eighth-grader.

Well over 100 parents attended the forum hosted by Hutchinson and the School Committee in the North Andover High School auditorium last night. One woman called the new system, in which traditional letter grades are replaced with numbers, “complete rubbish” and urged the committee to get rid of it.

Her suggestion drew applause.

The system is being used at North Andover Middle School. High school students still receive A’s, B’s, C’s, D’s and F’s. In the standards-based system, a 1 means no progress; 2 indicates improvement is needed; 3 stands for proficient; and a 4 reports advanced achievement.

Several parents complained their children had received 3’s even though they made no errors on a test. A number of middle-school teachers, however, said they like the new system because it gives a clearer picture of just how well a student is doing.

Stanley Novak, father of an eighth-grader, said his child got all the answers right on an algebra test – and received a grade of 2.5. Another child in that same class had five wrong answers – and also received a 2.5.

“Can somebody look into this?” Novak asked. Middle school Principal Joan McQuade suggested he tell her the name of the teacher.

Patty Dunbar said her child received a 2.5 for a test on which she gave correct answers to 29 out of 30 questions.

“That’s not right,” she said.

Hutchinson said after the meeting adjourned that those and other inconsistencies need to be resolved. Administrators will be working with teachers to make grades more consistent next week, he said.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Merrimack Valley

Eagle-Tribune News Videos
Photos of the Week