EagleTribune.com, North Andover, MA


November 7, 2012

Editorial: Libertarians play spoiler in two big races

“Fringe” candidates often get short shrift from the media in the public, but in at least two election contests this week they showed their ability to have a huge impact on the outcome of closely watched, and heavily financed, races. In both cases, the fringe appeal of the relatively poorly financed Libertarian Party was a race-spoiler for Republicans.

The most notable example was the race in Massachusetts between Democratic Congressman John Tierney and Republican Richard Tisei in the 6th District. It was an extremely close race, with Tisei finally conceding 18 hours after the polls closed.

Tierney garnered 48.3 percent of the vote, and Tisei 47.3 percent of the vote. The other 4.4 percent — a margin that guaranteed Tierney a win — went to Daniel Fishman, a Libertarian. Certainly, Fishman’s smaller-government political ideology is closer to the Republican platform than the Democratic platform. It’s safe to assume that had Fishman not been in the race, the bulk of his votes would have floated to Tisei, and perhaps today it would be Tisei who is heading to Washington.

Fishman was a little-known, politically inexperienced candidate who held to the Libertarian message that government should be less obtrusive in people’s lives, and that neither the Democratic nor the Republican party holds to the principals of freedom set down by the founding fathers. This software engineer made a big impact in one of the nation’s most closely watched congressional races.

An almost identical situation occurred in New Hampshire’s 1st District. Democrat Carol Shea-Porter won back her former seat by defeating Republican Congressman Frank Guinta. The margin was not quite as close as in the Tierney-Tisei race — Shea-Porter had 49 percent, and Guinta had 46 percent.

Once again, it was the fringe candidate who made the difference. Seabrook’s Brendan Kelly, a Libertarian, grabbed the remaining 5 percent of votes, a margin that likely would have pushed Guinta over the top had those votes fallen to him.

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Helium debate
Political News